Grasshopper New Media Presents...

GNMParents header image 2

Handwriting Matters

November 12th, 2007 by Whitney Hoffman · 6 Comments

kid's letter to Nana - handwrittenSo for a long time, people have thought my obsession with my children’s lousy handwriting, and that of my husband, for that matter, seemed quirky. Yet, in recent research out of Vanderbilt University by Dr. Steve Graham, we’ve found out that the ability to handwrite is tied to our ability to express ourselves fluently.

In the article that appeared in Newsweek Magazine, many teachers haven’t been trained to teach handwriting, nor have parents been told it’s a building block of learning, and something to spend time on at home. It turns out, handwriting fluency is not just a quaint old-fashioned skill, but is a building block to expressive language skills. Through handwriting, kids learn to take what they hear and read, and learn how to mentally manipulate it, transpose it, and then re-encode all this information into original thought and writing.

So for all of you who read GNM Parents, take the time to make sure your children work on handwriting. Workbooks that are fun and easy are available at very low cost- under $5.00 through Handwriting Without Tears- in five minutes a day you can make a significant impact on your child’s handwriting and on their education. Take it from someone who has children struggling with this issue now. Middle school is a little late to be re-training a child’s penmanship. And since schools are not devoting any time to it, you will need to work on this at home to improve it.

-Note- Both of my children are good typists, and the oldest now has an Alphasmart to use in school every day. However, knowing how to type has not “saved” them as everyone assumes. Too many worksheets and spelling tests require handwriting; standardized tests require handwritten essays- even colleges require students to handwrite in bluebooks.

Moreover, the delays in their written expression skills has been directly related to the difficulty they have in handwriting. They have become minimalists, writing as little as possible to get them by. Once this becomes a habit, asking them to express themselves in longer, more eloquent ways, is quite difficult.

Please, everyone- take handwriting, good band and indifferent seriously, and make sure your kids feel comfortable handwriting. Make sure they can do so speedily and automatically. You won’t be sorry.
Here’s an excerpt from the Newsweek article:

    All this matters, educators say, because evidence is growing that handwriting fluency is a fundamental building block of learning. Emily Knapton, director of program development at Handwriting Without Tears, believes that “when kids struggle with handwriting, it filters into all their academics. Spelling becomes a problem; math becomes a problem because they reverse their numbers. All of these subjects would be much easier for these kids to learn if handwriting was an automatic process.” That concern, in part, prompted the addition of a written essay to the SAT, which is graded for content, though not legibility. “If you put something like a writing test on the SAT, children’s skill level will begin to be addressed,” says Ed Hardin, a senior content specialist at the College Board. The trickle-down effect to middle schools should eventually reach third grade, where the trouble so often begins.


    No one is predicting, or even recommending, a return to the days when children obsessively practiced the curlicues on their Palmer Method capitals. Beauty seems to be less important than fluidity and speed. Graham’s work, and others’, has shown that from kindergarten through fourth grade, kids think and write at the same time. (Only later is mental composition divorced from the physical process of handwriting.) If they have to struggle to remember how to make their letters, their ability to express themselves will suffer. The motions have to be automatic, both for expressive writing and for another skill that students will need later in life, note-taking. “Measures of speed among elementary-school students are good predictors of the quality and quantity of their writing in middle school,” says Stephen Peverly, a professor of psychology and education at Columbia University’s Teachers College. “I don’t care about legibility.”


by Whitney Hoffman




[tags]kids, children, parents, parenting, handwriting, instruction, lessons, education, strategy, strategies, Columbia University’s Teachers College, Emily Knapton, Stephen Peverly, Ed Hardin, Newsweek, Handwriting Without Tears[/tags]

Photo graciously provided by kimberly hurst, through a Creative Commons license, some rights reserved

Tags: Activities · Education · Literacy · Parenting





6 responses so far ↓






  • AmyL // Nov 12, 2007 at 2:38 pm

    LOVE the HWT program! It’s inexpensive, straightforward, and makes sense. It’s really worth it to invest in the teacher’s edition as well because the author gives you a lot of tricks and strategies and explains how to teach the lessons.

  • Dee Schwartz // Nov 14, 2007 at 8:29 am

    As a proponent of teaching cursive writing early in education, I am now using this with the students that I teach at Park Tudor School. I made up my own penmanship program that works well for the highschool students , and have found that the flow of their thoughts becomes smoother and sequential in their writing. .

  • Kate Gladstone // Nov 14, 2007 at 2:29 pm

    As a handwriting instruction and remediation specialist, I work with a great many children, teens, and adults who have found their handwriting becoming worse during or soon after completion of “big name” print-then-cursive programs such as “Handwriting without Tears.” Those seeking some other approach to handwriting may enjoy visiting the Handwriting Repair web-site at http://www.learn.to/handwrite — or can always contact me privately via handwritingrepair@gmail.com if they or their organizations seek better handwriting for people of any age. (Yes, I work with doctors too!)

  • AmyL // Nov 15, 2007 at 10:31 pm

    I could see that being true with some of the other programs, but HWT was written by an Occupational Therapist. The letters are straight and easy to form, and are sized so that lower case letters are half the size of upper case. Also, there’s no slant to the cursive, which looks a great deal similar to the printed letters. While the product is not all fancy and flowing, it’s neat and easily read.

    I looked at the samples on your web site, and I don’t see how that’s vastly superior to the HWT writing. I do recognize that you’re showing improvement after one or two sessions. How about long-term results?

  • Kate Gladstone // Aug 31, 2008 at 7:40 pm

    “Handwriting Without Tears” unfortunately retains enough unnecessary complications to derail a fair number of students.AmyL, in your opinion, should I use HWTears with the students who have already wept over (and failed through) the complexities it still hasn’t gotten rid of?

  • Bianca Summons // Jan 15, 2009 at 12:47 am

    Dee – if you read this, could you please send me details of your program for high school students? I have a 12-year-old student who was never taught how to print, and I (and his mother!) think that learning to do so would consequently improve the state of his currently messy cursive. Too many programs are for elementary-schoolers with not enough materials available for older ones. Many thanks in advance!

Leave a Comment

Powered by WP Hashcash








Positive Parenting Is The Path To World Peace
We believe parenting (that is to say, positive parenting) is the key to happiness, because it provides children with a base of comfort, which allows them to grow. Our focus on parenting has everything to do with creating a better, safer, more pleasant society. Are you interested in increasing your focus on parenting? If so, give us some of your time. :-)