Editor’s Note: Please welcome Jennifer Lance, who is participating in a Green article swap between GNMParents and Green Options. Jennifer is a regular over at Green Options, a great site which succeeds in their efforts to “provide a place where you can sort out the flash from the trash, and make informed decisions that allow you to live a responsible, healthy and abundant life.” Tiffany’s regularly scheduled “A Little Greener” post can be found at this Green Options link. Thanks for visiting, Jennifer!
Every baby should wear cloth diapers. The benefits to you, your family, your baby, and the environment are endless. Cloth diapers are healthier, greener, and less expensive.
There are many health concerns associated with disposable diaper use, as these products are filled with chemicals and gels to absorb odor and moisture. Some chemically sensitive children have allergic reactions and diaper rashes from these substances. In fact, disposable diapers have been linked the development of asthma. The Archives of Environmental Health tested six leading cotton and disposable diaper brands for asthma effects. The emissions from one disposable diaper were high enough to produce asthma-like symptoms in mice. Tolune, xylene, ethylbenzene, styrene, and isopropylbenzene are all chemicals that outgas from disposable diapers. Not surprisingly, the study found that cloth diapers do not cause respiratory problems among the lab mice. Disposable diapers have also been linked to male infertility. Diapers that are lined with plastic do not allow air to circulate around the child’s bottom, which contributes to diaper rash and keeps the baby boy’s testicles too warm, thus impeding the normal development of the testicles. According to the Archives of Disease in Childhood, disposable diapers lead to a total breakdown of normal cooling mechanisms and raise the temperature of the scrotum far above normal body temperature. (Source: Nicki’s Diapers). Cloth diapers prevent this problem, as the natural fibers allow air to circulate around the child’s bottom, as long as the covers used are not made of latex or plastic.
Cloth diapers are better for the environment, as they are reusable and can be saved for the next child. Quality cotton diapers will hold up for 75 – 100 washings (at minimum), and although energy is required for washing the diapers, it is a fraction of the energy used for disposables. Cloth diapers also make wonderful, washable, household rags (once children have completed their toilet learning). According to Eartheasy, “It’s estimated that 10,000 tons of disposable diapers are tossed into landfills each day. They can take up to 500 years to decompose! The manufacture of disposables uses over 1 million metric tons of wood pulp and 75,000 metric tons of plastic each year. Disposables are the diaper of choice for over 80% of North American parents.†There’s a reason the green community calls disposable diapers “landfill diapersâ€!
The average parent spends $2,694.54 for 7,349 disposable, single-use diapers (source: Natural Family Online). In contrast, my family has spent under $200 during two children’s diapering years (we live off the grid, so there are no energy related costs). My second child is using the same diapers and covers his sister used as a babe. We store the dirty diapers in a plastic action packer container and wash them in warm water. We do not use bleach, but we do use vinegar in the rinse cycle to remove any laundry soap that may remain on the diapers. We also add a little Bi-O-Kleen Bac-Out Stain and Odor Eliminator in with the detergent to eliminate odors. A little squirt of this product in the diaper pail also helps eliminate odors when you open the lid. The most economical covers I have found are the Bummis Super Whisper Wrap. This product is adjustable, so the covers last as your child grows therefore reducing the need to buy many different sizes. Both of my babies were big, so we skipped the newborn size. Cotton Babies has a lot of great products, resources, and even a forum you can join regarding cloth diapering. You can read about the Joy of Cloth Diapers in Mothering magazine. Do the right thing…..USE CLOTH DIAPERS!
Have you ever wondered what families in third world countries or far back in history did for diapers? The National Resource Defense Council’s “This Green Life” answers this question and asks: should the debate be about cloth vs. disposable diapers at all? There is a third alternative that is better for the environment.
In North America, we assume diapers are a normal part of infancy and toddler hood, but it doesn’t have to be that way. Having a diaper less babe works like this, according to Sheryl Eisenburg of This Green Life, “The method goes by a variety of names: elimination communication, natural infant hygiene and infant potty training, though the last is spurned by many who say there is no training involved. Whatever it’s called, it boils down to this: the parent looks for the signals (hand-clenching, grunting, squirming, a look of inner concentration, etc.) that the baby regularly shows in advance of having to go, then takes the infant to the pot, sink or potty, and makes a special “cuing” noise — for instance, “sss” — to signal back that it’s ok to proceed. Soon the baby makes the association. The family now has a communication system that can be used to avoid messes most of the time.â€
For more information read:
[tags]green, parenting, benefits of cloth diapers, diaper debate, disposable diapers, benefits of cloth[/tags]
Photo graciously provided by a11sus, through a Creative Commons license, some rights reserved












9 responses so far ↓
jen // May 8, 2007 at 4:57 pm
This is really interesting. I had no idea about all those chemicals used in disposables.
I used cloth nappies (as we call them here) for my son 70-80% of the time and I was the only one of my peers to do so at the time. It honestly didn’t bother me and I knew I was saving heaps of money doing so and doing my little bit to help the environment.
I passed on my cloth nappies to a friend who uses them for her son.
Barb // May 8, 2007 at 7:38 pm
Jen,
Great article! I started using cloth diapers when my oldest son was 2 years old and I read Diaper Changes: The Complete Diapering Book and Resource Guide. I love them! In fact, I became a “cloth diaper addict”.
My favorite, for sake of ease, have been Fuzzi Bunz, and those are the only kind we have now. My youngest son, who is now 2, is using the Fuzzi Bunz that his older brother – and then his older sister – both used.
For people who are unsure about the ease of using cloth or want to wait before making the commitment, there are earth friendly disposable diapers, and even the newer hybrid-like G Diapers ( http://www.gdiapers.com ). These have a flushable liner, so there’s no washing poopy diapers involved, and they have adorable covers.
That’s one of the best parts about cloth diapering – they are WAY cuter than disposables any day. Even the solid colored Fuzzi Bunz are cuter than the cartoons on a Pampers diaper.
Washing them has been almost as easy as washing other clothes, and the couple of extra steps are worth it for our children’s health and the health of our planet. I, like you, love Bac-Out.
I look forward to reading your future “trade” posts here at GNMParents!
Jennifer Lance // May 9, 2007 at 9:48 pm
Thank you Jen and Barb for sharing your experiences with cloth diapers/nappies. I love the term nappies! I tried using it with my two year old son, but he kept thinking I was talking about taking naps.
I’m not sure how I feel about the gdiapers. My partner brought them home one day by mistake, when I asked him to pick up some Seventh Generation diapers for a trip. I took them back, as we didn’t have the covers. We have a septic system, and I don’t think flushing the liners down would be good for it. Plus, adding to a city’s sewage treatment system may not be such a grand idea either, unless you live somewhere with a marsh system. But gdiapers may just be what some families can do, so it is a good alternative.
Cloth Diapers // May 16, 2007 at 6:43 pm
Great article … thank you
kim // May 16, 2007 at 6:44 pm
Great source of information. Thank you.
I like http://www.thediaperhyena.com for information on using and caring for cloth diapers.
Jeff // May 21, 2007 at 6:19 pm
Right on! My wife and I used Fuzzi Bunz Cloth Diapers for our girl and while the upfront cost is alarming (at best) the downstream impact of NOT buying pack after pack of disposables featuring the branded character du jour is priceless. We tried a couple different brands (Mother Ease being one of them) before settling on Fuzzi Bunz, which are amazing. Can’t wait to use them for baby #2 and reap even more of the cost benefit!
…all that and I did not even mention the positive environmental imact!
MeMoBaby // Jun 19, 2007 at 8:51 am
THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!! I have been trying to convince all my new mama friends about the benefits of cloth diapering – they all think I am nuts. I had no idea about all of the health benefits as well. This is an amazing post – thanks SO MUCH for sharing!
Carrie // Jul 5, 2007 at 4:51 pm
I have bought and sold used cloth diapers so I think the recycling factor for cloth diapers is a definite plus!. And I love that they don’t have stupid cartoon characters on them that I don’t even let my children watch anyway.
I also use cloth diaper wipes and encourage everyone else to. Here is a good site with some good links for diaper sewing and diaper wipe recipes http://www.thewishingwellness.com/
Helena // Jan 3, 2010 at 10:30 pm
Glad to see cloth diapering growing. http://www.thanksmama.com will help you further for all your cloth diapering needs
Leave a Comment